The landlord or property manager is often responsible for the parking lot and common areas, the tenant for its own storefront sidewalk when the lease says so, and a snow contractor only for the areas its written contract names. The lease, who controls each area and the local ordinance decide it. Hiring a contractor moves the work. It does not always move the legal duty.
The rules differ by state, province and city, so this page says which country each point applies to, and it names the places where we read the rule. It is general information, not legal advice. For a specific lease, contract or claim, talk to a lawyer where the property is, and to your insurer.
Who is responsible for snow removal on a commercial property, in short?
- The lease comes first. It is the document that says who clears what. Where it is silent or unclear, a court may ask who controlled the area.
- Landlords and property managers often carry the parking lot, drive aisles, fire lanes and shared walkways. In the Minnesota snow contractor’s article we read, the landlord is the one who hires the snow company for those areas.
- Tenants are often given the sidewalk directly in front of their unit, depending on the lease. A triple net lease can put more of it on the tenant.
- A contractor is responsible for what its written contract covers. Who is liable to a person who falls is a separate question.
- The city’s ordinance applies on top of the lease. It can name the owner or occupant of the property, whatever the lease says between them.
Does the lease decide who clears the snow?
Between a landlord and a tenant, the lease is where the answer starts. A Minnesota snow contractor’s article on strip malls calls the lease the governing document for nearly every maintenance responsibility, snow removal included, and says that where the lease is silent the question falls back on general premises liability law. Marshall Dennehey, a Pennsylvania law firm, makes the same point in its September 2025 Defense Digest: the lease should say who is responsible for snow and ice removal.
Marshall Dennehey’s article describes two Pennsylvania cases. In one (Stuski), the property owner was not liable because the lease clearly put snow and ice removal on the tenant. In the other (Eisbacher), the lease did not clearly say who controlled a trailer drop lot that was not shown as a common area, the court found a real question about who controlled it, and a jury had to decide. A vague lease leaves the question open for a court to answer after someone is hurt.
Two lease terms change who pays even when they do not change who is responsible. Common area maintenance (CAM) charges can pass the landlord’s snow bill to the tenants as a share of common-area costs, and the Minnesota article says a triple net lease can leave snow removal with the tenant entirely.
Who usually handles which area of a commercial property?
The first two rows come from one Minnesota snow contractor’s article on strip malls (KG Landscape), and they are that contractor’s account, not a rule. The last row comes from the city pages further down. Read your own lease for the real split.
| Area | Often handled by | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Parking lot, fire lanes, shared walkways, dumpster areas | Landlord or property manager, through its snow contractor | Shared by every tenant and customer, so no one tenant controls them |
| Sidewalk directly in front of a unit, entrance, tenant’s outdoor space | The tenant, when the lease says so | The landlord’s responsibility generally stops at the front edge of the sidewalk |
| Public sidewalk along the street | Set by the local ordinance | The city can name the owner, the occupant or itself |
What does control of the area have to do with it?
In law, the duty to keep people reasonably safe on a property follows the occupier, and in the two Canadian statutes we read, an occupier is defined by possession or control, not by title alone. As of November 2026, they say so in nearly the same words.
- Ontario (Canada). In the Occupiers’ Liability Act an occupier includes “a person who is in physical possession of premises” and “a person who has responsibility for and control over the condition of premises or the activities there carried on, or control over persons allowed to enter the premises”, “despite the fact that there is more than one occupier of the same premises” (s. 1). The duty is “such care as in all the circumstances of the case is reasonable” (s. 3(1)). Read November 18, 2026, on Ontario e-Laws.
- British Columbia (Canada). The Occupiers Liability Act defines an occupier as a person who “is in physical possession of premises” or “has responsibility for, and control over, the condition of premises, the activities conducted on those premises and the persons allowed to enter those premises”, and says “there may be more than one occupier of the same premises” (s. 1). The duty is to take “that care that in all the circumstances of the case is reasonable” (s. 3(1)). Read November 18, 2026, on BC Laws, which showed the Act as current to November 17, 2026.
- United States. Premises liability comes from each state’s own law, and we did not read all fifty. Rocket Lawyer’s guide, last reviewed December 9, 2024, says that generally whoever owns the property is responsible for removing snow and ice from its walkways, and that duties can also come from leases, HOA rules and service contracts. One of the Pennsylvania cases in Marshall Dennehey’s article (Eisbacher) turned on who controlled the drop lot, and the other (Stuski) turned on a lease that clearly assigned the work to the tenant, though the court also said liability rests on possession and control, not ownership alone.
So a tenant who controls its storefront walk can be an occupier of it, and the landlord who controls the lot can be an occupier of the lot. Both can be occupiers of the same place. The lease sets who agreed to do the work, and under these two statutes possession or control is what makes a person an occupier.
Both statutes also speak to landlords who keep the maintenance of a tenancy. Ontario s. 8(1) says that where premises are occupied or used “by virtue of a tenancy under which the landlord is responsible for the maintenance or repair of the premises”, the landlord owes “the same duty of care in respect of dangers arising from any failure on the landlord’s part in carrying out the landlord’s responsibility” as an occupier. BC’s s. 6(1) is to the same effect. So a landlord who kept the lot in the lease owes the same care for a failure to clear it.
Does hiring a snow contractor move the responsibility?
It moves the work, and sometimes part of the risk. It does not hand the owner’s duty over wholesale, and the two statutes we read show why.
- Ontario, s. 6(1). Where an independent contractor employed by the occupier is negligent, the occupier “is not on that account liable” if it “acted reasonably in entrusting the work to the independent contractor”, took the steps it reasonably ought “in order to be satisfied that the contractor was competent and that the work had been properly done”, and it was reasonable that the work be done at all. Section 6(3) adds that nothing in that section “affects any duty of the occupier that is non-delegable at common law”.
- British Columbia, s. 5(1) and (2). The occupier is not liable under the Act for an independent contractor’s negligence if it “exercised reasonable care in the selection and supervision of the independent contractor” and “it was reasonable that the work that the independent contractor was engaged to do should have been undertaken”. Subsection (2) says that does not restrict or exclude liability imposed by any other Act.
- Ontario’s snow and ice notice, s. 6.1. For a personal injury claim caused by snow or ice, written notice within 60 days can go to an occupier or to “an independent contractor employed by the occupier to remove snow or ice on the premises”. A claim can reach the contractor as well as the owner. See Ontario’s 60-day notice.
In these two provinces, an owner who picked a competent contractor and watched the work can have a defence to a contractor’s mistake, and the owner who did neither has less of one. The contractor can still be named. Neither section we read says that hiring a contractor ends the owner’s duty. The Marshall Dennehey article’s own example fits: the landlord there had a contract with a snow removal service, and the court still looked at who controlled the area.
Contracts can also push liability around between the parties. A hold-harmless clause is one. The Accredited Snow Contractors Association (ASCA) says its model Snow Plow and Deicing Limited Liability Act “eliminates the practice of property owners and property managers passing on their liability” to snow and ice management companies, and that it has been signed into law in Illinois, Colorado, Connecticut and Pennsylvania. Whether a clause like that holds depends on the law where the property is, which is a question for a local lawyer. The contract clauses guide covers the clauses and the insurance guide covers the cover that sits behind them. If you are bidding a property like this, see how to bid commercial snow contracts.
Can a city ordinance override the lease?
A city ordinance applies on top of the lease: the lease decides who reimburses whom, but the city can still hold the owner or occupant to its rule. As of November 2026, two cities we read show how much the clock and the party can differ.
- New York City (United States). The Department of Sanitation’s snow page says you must clear a path in the sidewalk in front of your building, and sets the clock by when the snow stops: within 4 hours if it ends between 7:00 AM and 4:59 PM, within 14 hours if it ends between 5:00 PM and 8:59 PM, and by 11:00 AM if it ends between 9:00 PM and 6:59 AM. It names “building owners and occupants” for the areas around fire hydrants and for sidewalk ramps and curb-cuts. Read November 18, 2026, on the NYC Sanitation snow laws page.
- Toronto (Canada). The City’s sidewalk page says that for lighter snowfalls, residents and businesses clear the sidewalk next to their property within 12 hours after the snow ends, while the City’s crews clear public sidewalks after heavier snow, and that property owners clear ice and snow from private property, such as driveways, parking spaces, steps, ramps and landings, within 24 hours after snowfall ends. Read November 18, 2026, on the City of Toronto page.
Rocket Lawyer’s guide says some states and local governments have their own snow laws, while others have none, and that premises liability law itself sets no fixed deadline as long as the owner tries to reduce the risk of injury. Its New York City example is that owners do not have to clear while it is still snowing, but must within a set time after it stops. On when a duty starts outside a city ordinance, the pages we read don’t say more, and Marshall Dennehey’s article does not address it. So the ordinance in the town where the property sits is the third document to read, after the lease and the contract.
Who is responsible for each area of a strip mall? A worked example
This is a made-up property to show the method, with every input stated. It is not a legal finding, and your lease and your town’s ordinance will differ.
The inputs. One landlord owns a strip mall with 6 tenants. The property has 10 areas that need snow work: the parking lot, the fire lane, a shared walkway along the back, a dumpster pad, and 6 storefront sidewalks, one in front of each unit. The lease puts the lot, the fire lane, the shared walkway and the dumpster pad on the landlord (4 areas) and each storefront sidewalk on its tenant (6 areas). The landlord hires a snow contractor under a written scope that lists the lot, the fire lane and the shared walkway (3 areas). The scope is plowing only: de-icing is not mentioned, and it says nothing about the dumpster pad or the storefront sidewalks. For the money step, the contractor’s season bill for those 3 areas is a made-up $18,000, and the lease’s CAM clause (an assumption for this example) passes that bill to the 6 tenants by leased square feet: 1,000, 1,000, 1,500, 1,500, 2,000 and 3,000 square feet, 10,000 in all.
| Area | Lease says | Contractor’s scope says | Who to look to first |
|---|---|---|---|
| Parking lot | Landlord | Covered | Landlord, and its contractor for the work |
| Fire lane | Landlord | Covered | Landlord, and its contractor for the work |
| Shared back walkway | Landlord | Covered | Landlord, and its contractor for the work |
| Dumpster pad | Landlord | Not listed | Landlord, with nobody assigned to do it |
| 6 storefront sidewalks | Each tenant | Not listed | The tenant for each unit |
- Count the areas. 10 areas in all: 4 on the landlord and 6 on tenants.
- Count what the contract covers. The contractor’s scope covers 3 of the landlord’s 4 areas, which leaves 1 area of 10 that the lease gives to the landlord and no one has been hired to clear. That is the gap, and it is the dumpster pad.
- Follow the money. The CAM share is $18,000 divided by 10,000 square feet, which is $1.80 a square foot. The 1,000 square foot units pay $1,800 each, the 1,500 square foot units $2,700 each, the 2,000 square foot unit $3,600 and the 3,000 square foot unit $5,400. Those add up to $18,000. Nobody is billed for the dumpster pad, because nobody was hired to clear it.
- Check the tenants’ 6. The contractor does not touch them, so each tenant needs its own plan or must ask the landlord to add its sidewalk to the scope, with the lease or a side agreement saying who pays.
- Check de-icing. Plowing and de-icing are separate events. The scope here lists plowing only, so ask whether anyone salts the lot, and who salts the tenants’ walks.
- Check where one area ends and the next begins. If the lease calls the strip between a curb cut and a storefront “the sidewalk” and the contractor’s scope calls it “the lot”, two parties each think the other has it. Draw the line on a site plan and attach it to both documents.
- Say what happens if someone falls. A customer who falls on a tenant’s storefront sidewalk may name the tenant, the landlord and the contractor. The lease, the scope and the visit records will be the first things anyone asks to see, and who controlled that sidewalk will be a large part of the question.
The fix is cheap to write down: add the dumpster pad to the contractor’s scope (the price may change) or to the landlord’s own plan, say in the scope whether de-icing is included, add a site plan to the lease and to the scope, and agree who tells whom when the tenants’ walks are not clear.
What should landlords, tenants and contractors each do?
- Landlords and property managers: list every area in the lease or a site plan, name who clears each, write a contractor scope that matches it area by area, pick a contractor that carries the insurance your lease asks for, and keep the visit records. Property managers can also use these storm communication templates to tell tenants what is happening.
- Tenants: read the snow clause before you sign, ask for a plan that shows your area, and keep your own record of when your walk was cleared and salted. If the lease gives you the storefront sidewalk, find out whether your town’s ordinance also names you.
- Contractors: ask for the lease’s snow clause or a site plan, write the areas you cover into the contract, name the areas you do not, and keep a record for every visit. A scope that says “the property” invites a dispute about the dumpster pad.
How do you keep records that show who did what?
After a fall, the first questions are what the lease said, what the contract covered and what was done at the site and when. The contract and the lease are paper you already have. The record of what was done has to be made on the night. The slip-and-fall documentation guide lists what to keep, and the proof-of-service checklist lists what a client should be shown.
We make Icey Software. Its crew app, Field Mode, records when the crew started and finished at each site, where the phone was, and photos at every site. Each completed visit makes a site report that stays on the job, so you can show which visits were made and when. Icey does not decide who is responsible. The lease, the contract and the law do that. It keeps the record of the work. Free forever up to 10 sites and unlimited crew. Every feature.
Sources
- Occupiers’ Liability Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. O.2, ss. 1, 3(1), 6, 6.1 and 8, on Ontario e-Laws, read November 18, 2026 through the site’s own data feed, which carries the same consolidated text.
- Occupiers Liability Act, RSBC 1996, c. 337, ss. 1, 3, 5 and 6, on BC Laws, current to November 17, 2026 as the page says, read November 18, 2026.
- KG Landscape, “Who is Responsible for Snow Removal at Plymouth Strip Malls?”, a Minnesota snow contractor’s article with no date on the page, read November 18, 2026: the lease as the governing document, the usual landlord and tenant split, CAM charges, triple net leases, and that both landlord and tenant can be named.
- Marshall Dennehey, “Dealing With Snow in Summer”, Defense Digest, September 1, 2025, on Pennsylvania cases, read November 18, 2026: the lease should say who is responsible, and the cases where the lease was clear and where control of an area was disputed.
- Rocket Lawyer, how quickly snow and ice need to be removed, last reviewed December 9, 2024, read November 18, 2026: owners generally responsible for walkways, duties from leases, HOA rules and service contracts, local snow laws, and no fixed deadline in premises liability law.
- NYC Sanitation, snow and ice laws and City of Toronto, clearing snow and ice from your property, each read November 18, 2026: the two ordinance examples.
- ASCA, about the ASCA, read November 18, 2026: the model Snow Plow and Deicing Limited Liability Act and the four states it names.
- General information, not legal advice. Laws and city rules change, so read the current text for your state, province or city, and ask a local lawyer about any specific lease, contract or claim. We could not read the Scarinci Hollenbeck page on New Jersey landlords (a browser check blocked it), so nothing here rests on it.
Frequently Asked Questions
Who is responsible for snow removal in a commercial lease?
Whoever the lease names. Landlords often keep the parking lot, drive aisles and common areas, and tenants are often given the sidewalk in front of their unit. Where the lease is silent, the question usually turns on who controls the area, and a local ordinance can name the owner or occupant whatever the lease says. General information, not legal advice.
Is the landlord or the tenant responsible for the parking lot?
Often the landlord, because a lot is shared by every tenant and customer and the landlord keeps control of it. In the Minnesota snow contractor’s article we read, the landlord arranges the clearing through a contractor and passes the cost to tenants through common area maintenance (CAM) charges. A triple net lease can put more of it on the tenant, so read the lease.
Does hiring a snow contractor make the contractor liable instead of me?
Not on its own. In Ontario and British Columbia, the statutes we read give an occupier a defence to a contractor’s negligence only if it acted reasonably in choosing and overseeing the contractor, and neither section says that hiring a contractor ends the owner’s duty. The contractor can still be named in a claim. ASCA, a snow contractors’ trade association, says its model bill has been signed into law in Illinois, Colorado, Connecticut and Pennsylvania. What a hold-harmless clause can do depends on the law where the property is.
Can both the landlord and the tenant be sued after a slip and fall?
Yes. The statutes in Ontario and British Columbia say there may be more than one occupier of the same premises, and a claim can name the landlord, the tenant and the contractor together. The records of who controlled the area and who did the work are what each of them will need.
Can a city ordinance override the lease?
Not as against the city. A lease sets the deal between a landlord and a tenant, and it can decide who pays whom, but the city can still hold the owner or occupant of the property to its rule. Check the ordinance in the town where the property is.
Who is responsible for the sidewalk in front of a store?
It depends on the lease and the town. The Minnesota snow contractor’s article we read says tenants are usually responsible for the sidewalk along their storefront. For the public sidewalk, New York City’s page puts a path on the building’s owner or occupant, while Toronto’s says residents and businesses clear the sidewalk next to their property after lighter snowfalls and the City’s crews clear public sidewalks after heavier snow. Check both the lease and the ordinance.
What should a snow removal contract say about who is responsible?
It should list the areas the contractor covers and the areas it does not, ideally on a site plan, with the trigger depth and the clearing standard for each. A scope that says only “the property” leaves areas like dumpster pads and storefront walks in dispute. The contract clauses guide covers the rest.
Who is responsible when a property manager hires the contractor?
It turns on control. In the two Canadian statutes we read, a person with responsibility for and control over the condition of the premises can be an occupier, so a manager that controls the lot can be one, alongside the owner. The management agreement says who hired the contractor for whom, and the lease says what the owner promised the tenants. A local lawyer can say who answers for what where the property is.
Related guides
Run your snow business on Icey
Dispatch, GPS, salt logs, quoting, and e-sign contracts in one place. Free for companies with up to 10 sites — no demo call: sign up and add your first sites today.
Start free